by Steve Forbes, Jr.
My time with John Jacob Astor: An impossible interview made possible by one dream, one coffee and a century leap.
I often wonder what words of wisdom the early American real estate tycoons would give us if we could talk to them. Thoughts of traveling back in time to visit with John Jacob Astor were on my mind as I drifted off to sleep, and my subconscious created the meeting. Here’s how it went.
I’ll admit the time machine smelled like burnt toast and ozone, and I had no real plan beyond “find America’s first great real estate fortune and ask him what he’d tell a real estate professional in 2026.” Somehow it worked, and I landed on the porch of John Jacob Astor’s summer estate on the East River in Manhattan, New York. After introductions and John Jacob’s close inspection of my chino shorts and flip flops, he ushered me into his office. Ledgers were stacked like firewood on either side of a massive fireplace that I imagined put off some major heat in the winter months, and candles burned brightly from the mantle. He poured the coffee himself, and I wasted no time picking the brain of this brilliant business mogul.
_____
Me: Mr. Astor, you started as a fur trader and became, by most accounts, the wealthiest man in America — almost entirely through Manhattan real estate. What’s the first thing you’d tell a real estate agent today?
John Jacob Astor: That I bought, and then I waited. Other men bought to sell. I bought to own. New York was a small, dirty harbor town when I started buying lots north of it. It was land nobody else wanted yet. I did not need the money from any one piece. I needed all the pieces, together, for fifty years.
Me: Fifty years is a long hold for most agents’ clients today.
Astor: Then most agents are advising tenants, not owners. A man who needs his money back next season should rent a room, not buy a city.
_____
Me: How does a modern agent spot the kind of opportunity you saw; land that’s cheap now but won’t stay that way?
Astor: Watch where people are forced to go, not where they want to go. Harbors, crossroads, the only bridge for twenty miles. Geography doesn’t change its mind. Fashion does. I bought above the city’s edge because I knew the city had nowhere else to grow but north. I didn’t need to be clever. I only needed to be early and certain.
Me: And if you’re wrong about “certain”? Land is expensive to be wrong about.
Astor: Then you buy less of it, and you buy it with money you already have. I never staked my whole fortune on one parcel. I staked it on the city itself, hundreds of small bets in the same direction. One bad lot doesn’t ruin a man who owns a hundred good ones.
_____
Me: You’re famous for never selling. Why hold land that isn’t producing income yet?
Astor: Because the income was never the point. The position was. Rent was a courtesy the land paid me while I waited for its true value to arrive. I leased my lots rather than sold them whenever I could, so the land stayed mine even after another man built upon it. When his building burned or his business failed, the dirt underneath was still my dirt. Buildings are temporary. Position is not.
Me: That sounds almost like patience as a financial instrument.
Astor: It is the only instrument that has never failed me. Panics came…1819…1837 nearly broke half the merchants I knew. I didn’t sell into a panic. I bought into it when other men needed cash more than they needed land. Fear sells cheap. I always had the cash to be the buyer in the worst years.
_____
Me: Last question. If a real estate professional in 2026 could take only one lesson from your life, what should it be?
Astor: Don’t sell the corner lot because someone offers you twice what you paid. Someone will always offer twice what you paid. Sell it when it’s worth twenty times, and not a day before you’re ready to. In the meantime, buy the next corner with cash, not nerve.
_____
I marveled at his planning and plotting as he shared the details of how he turned the fortune he made in fur trading into a real estate empire that amassed generational wealth. These many years later, the advice holds up better than most modern hot takes on real estate: buy land people are forced toward, hold it longer than feels comfortable, let fear sell to you instead of the other way around, and never let borrowed nerve write your timeline for you.
Waking with a start, I took in my surroundings and realized I’d nodded off on the couch in my home office. Darting to my desk, the keyboard on my laptop clicked maniacally as I quickly keyed in every detail from my visit to Hellgate before the dream vanished from my memory. But was it a dream? Easing back in my chair as I pondered how real it felt to be sitting in Astor’s study, my eyes fell on the ornate cup and saucer perched on the end table beside my couch. Steam curled out of the cup, and I crept toward it with intrigue. It was filled with piping hot coffee, and a fine quill pen lay beside a note next to the saucer. In bold flourishes of ink, the note read:
Fascinating conversation, Steve!
JJA
Dream or time travel, one thing I know is certain. Astor’s Manhattan is unrecognizable now. His logic for buying it isn’t.